Your Five Star Favorites

What makes a Five Star hat? We ask ourselves this every day, but our customers answer it best: “Excellent fit and quality of finish leaves no doubt as to quality of product.” This collection showcases the hats and caps you’ve rated Five Stars, with reviews like “Exceeded my expectations tenfold… it is gorgeous and fits perfectly” and “This is my favorite place so far. Feels high quality and the price seems worth it.” This feedback confirms for us that while partnering directly with world-renowned hatmakers, sourcing the finest materials, and streamlining pricing may not always be the simplest path, it is the right one to honor our commitment to quality and value. The truth is, these hats aren’t just customer favorites, they’re some of ours too. Each design reflects hours spent developing hats that meet our expectations of style and lasting craftsmanship, while every review reminds us why we continue to raise the bar. Our mission is simple: to make sure every hat, and every experience, is truly worthy of five stars. That’s the heart of Mr. Belfry's Five Star Promise.